Sanyojana, Sannojana, Samyojana, Samyojana
The Three, Five, Ten Fetters; Yokes to Rebirth
Puremind Press, Venerable Punnaji, Awakening Meditation, pp 8-72
The Book of the Ones: The Yokes to Rebirth
Appendixes: The 10 Fundamantal Attachments
Discussion at: DhammaTalk: The Five Fetters to the Lower Rebirths
AN 4.131: Three sorts of yokes: To the lower worlds, to rebirth, and to existence.
SN 4.35.54, SN 4.35.55, the method for letting go of the s.
|Pali||MO||Hare||Horner||Punnaji||Bodhi||Nanamoli||Rhys Davids||(Mrs)Rhys Davids||Thanissaro||Walshe||Woodward|
|Sanyojana||Yokes, attachments, yokes to rebirth||Fetters||Fetters, the fetters of becoming||Entanglements||Fetters, the fetters of being||Fetters||fetters||fetters||Fetters||fetters||Fetters|
|Sakkayaditthi||One-truth-view; Own-body-view||References Rhys Davids||Own-Body||Personality perspective, self concept||personality view||personality view||delusion of self, error of permanant individual entity||error of permanant individual entity||self-identity views||personality-belief||The view of the individual-group|
|Vicikiccha||doubt, vacillation||References Rhys Davids||doubt, perplexity||Vacillation||doubt||doubt||doubt||doubt||Uncertainty||sceptical doubt||doubt and wavering|
|Silabbata-paramaso||attachment to trust in good works, ethics and rituals||References Rhys Davids||clinging to rites and customs||alientation of morals||adherence to rules and observances||adherence to rules and observances||Reliance on the efficacy of rites and ceremonies, wrong judgment as to rules and ritual||wrong judgment as to rules and ritual||grasping at precepts and practices||attachment to rite and ritual||wrong handling of habit-and-ritual|
|Kamacchanda||wanting, pleasure-wishing||References Rhys Davids||desire for sense pleasures||Sensual desire, sensual lust||sensual lust, covetousness||sensual lust, covetousness||bodily lusts or passions, sensuality||sensuality||Sensual Desire||sensuality||sensual desire, hankering|
|Vyapado||anger, hate, the by-path||References Rhys Davids||malevolance, ill-will||Hate||ill will||ill will||ill-will||ill-will||ill-will, malevolance||ill-will||malevolence, ill-will|
|Ruparago||Lust for material things||References Rhys Davids||Lust for corporeality||form, materiality/lust||form, materiality/lust||lust after rebirth in Rupa (worlds)||lust after rebirth in Rupa (worlds)||passion for form||craving for the world of form||Lust of objective form|
|Aruparago||lust for immaterial things||References Rhys Davids||Lust for in-corporeality||immateriality, immaterial realm/lust||immateriality, immaterial realm/lust||lust after rebirth in Arupa (worlds)||lust after rebirth in Arupa (worlds)||passion for what is formless||craving for the formless world||lust of the formless|
|Mana||pride||References Rhys Davids||identity, self esteem (positive or negative)||conceit||conceit||pride, conceit||conceit||conceit||conceit||conceit|
|Uddhaccan||trembling||References Rhys Davids||restlessness||Anxiety||restlessness||restlessness||Self-righteousness, excitement||excitement||restlessness, worry||distraction||excitement, Restlessness|
|Avijja||blindness||References Rhys Davids||ignorance||unconsciousness||ignorance||ignorance||ignorance||ignorance||ignorance||ignorance||ignorance|
Pali Text Society
Pali English Dictionary
Edited by T. W. Rhys Davids and William Stede
Sanyoga: [fr. san+yuj] 1. bond, fetter M I.498; S I.226; III.70; IV.36; A IV.280...-- 2. union, association... --3. connection (within the sentence), construction (accanta-)...
Sanyojana[fr. sanyunjati] bond, fetter S IV.163 etc.; especially the fetters that bind man to the wheel of transmigration Vin I.183; S I.23; V.241, 251; A I.264; III.443; IV.7 sq. (ditthi-); M I.483; J I.275;.
The ten fetters are (1) sakkayaditthi; (2) vicikiccha; (3) silabbataparamaso; (4) kamacchando; (5) vyapado; (6) ruparago; (7) aruparago; (8) mano; (9) uddhaccam; (10) avijja. The first three are the tini sanyojanani e. g. M I.9; A I.231, 233; D I.156; II.92 sq., 252; III.107, 132, 216; S V.357, 376, 406. The seven last are the satta sanyojanani. The first five are called orambhagiyani e. g. A I.232 sq.; II.5, 133; V.17; D I.156; II.92, 252; M I.432; S V.61, 69. The last five are called uddhambhagiyani e. g. A V.17; S V.61, 69. A diff. enumn of seven sanyojanas at D III.254 and A IV.7, viz. anunaya-, patigha-, ditthi-, vicikiccha-, mana-, bhavaraga-, avijja-. A list of eight is found at M I.361 sq. Cp. also ajjhatta-sanyojano and bahiddhasanyojano puggalo A I.63 sq.; kim-su-s- S I.39.
[AN 4.131] Sanyojana Puggala Suttam the Pali,
Fetters, Woodward translation.
The Buddha describes four sorts of persons in relationship to the sorts of yokes to rebirth [sanyogana] they have or have not yet got rid of.
This sutta raises many important issues. First is an unusual breakdown of the sanyoganas:
1. those yoking one to rebirth in the lower worlds Woodward translates 'this World' and then, for the Once Returner translates in a way that can be misunderstood as indicating that he has not broken any of the first five fetters (this, apparently, an opinion derived from commentary). But these are yokes to any 'kama-loka' which includes the deva-worlds up to the Tusita Realm - see the Buddhist cosmology here - These first five yokes are: 1. The One-truth view, 2. Doubt, 3. Belief that good deeds, ethical conduct or rituals can bring an end to Pain, 4. Wishing for pleasure, 5. Deviant thinking. When the first three of these are broken by the Streamwinner, he is no longer subject to rebirth lower than the world of humans. He is able to see when he is hanging on to a way of viewing his individuality that will lead him to hell or some other low state and is able to let that go without having the strength to let go of every sort of being. The Once-returner is also a Streamwinner, so he will have at least broken the first three yokes. The Buddha is in this case speaking of the category as a whole, not it's individual components. He does not say 'has not broken any fetters' he says 'has not broken the 'orambhagiyani sanyojanani.' All five.
2. those yoking one to rebirth
3. those yoking one to existence.
Bhkkhu Bodhi cites the commentary for definition of the last two and the result is a restatement of the terms with nothing informative added.
You are welcome to disagree, but I suggest we do not need to go off into bizarre speculations relying on the commentary to understand these last two categories. It is sufficient to carefully examine the nature of the 10 sanyojanani that we are given.
First, to understand the latter two categories, one must understand fetter #1: sakkayaditthi. The usual understanding is that this means 'view of self' understanding that to mean the idea one has that one has an eternal self, etc. (Actually the usual understanding is to flip to the view that there is no self, but that is just an error.) The emphasis should be on the 'view' part of the compound. The holding onto points of view concerning individuality with the idea: 'This alone is the truth, all other views are stupidity.' The Streamwinner who has freed himself from this yoke will have understood that the problem of pain arises as a result of the holding on to a view concerning his having an eternal self, but he will not necessarily have actually abandoned the identification, thoughts, and so forth that arise from having had that point of view in the past. Its like the phantom limb phenomena. He is likened to the person who has come across a well without a bucket to retrieve the water. He can see the solution (as it were) but has not got the means to drink.
In a similar way all the first five fetters have to do with orienting the intellect to the goal and focusing the individual's behavior on elimination of various gross obstructions to perception of his inner workings. These first five do not constitute having uprooted the underlying drive to be. The next two fetters are lust for form and lust for immaterial existence: the underlying drives to be, aka: yokes to actual rebirth.
The final three yokes are pride, a fear-ridden-anxiety, and being subject to misunderstanding (aka blindness). Here we have the case of the person who has sufficient experience to prevent him from behavior that would result in rebirth in any realm of being, but for whatever reason (long habit, experience, difficult circumstances) there remain these subtle states of mind. This is the case of the Non-Returner who no longer own-makes (sankharams) and who obtains final release at some point after the death of the body but before assuming any rebirth.
There is much discussion back and forth concerning the precise state this individual is in caused by trying to imagine a state of existence which does not require rebirth. A between-births. But this is not necessary if one examines AN 11.7 and similar suttas where it is stated that there is the possibility of perception without perception of any realm of being. 'Existence' is a matter of perception, rebirth is a matter of having acted upon perception to the effect of having set rolling identification with form or the formless. The Paticca Samuppada differentiates between bhava and jati: existence and rebirth. This person is percipient of these subtle mental states. That is what remains for him of existence. That is what he gets rid of, without assuming rebirth, to become Arahant.