Don't let the gloves intimidate you; the gloves are off.

[Home]  [Sutta Indexes]  [Glossology]  [Site Sub-Sections]


 [Dhamma Talk]


SN 4.40.1

Moggallāna, one of the two most powerful of the Buddha's followers, and the one whose strong point was magic power, describes his first attempts to master the level of meditation practice called the First Jhāna.

Read the Sutta

Recommended translation: With Thought, Olds translation
Index of Available translations: SN 4.40.1



The problem with Woodward's translation/conception of jhāna is his use of the term 'trance'. The jhānas, at a certain point definitely resemble or might as well be called trances, but the implication of the word distorts the reality.

What these states are is wide-awake, fully conscious awareness of higher than ordinary states of reality.

The word 'jhāna' is the root of our word 'knowing' and it would be best to emphasize that aspect of jhāna over the fact that from the outside the individual highly concentrated in jhāna seems to be in a trance state.

In later translations he uses the term 'musing' which is somewhat closer to what is happening.

I have pointed out in notes, in and through my translation, where I believe commentarial explanations have distorted the understanding of the first jhāna.

The importance of this sutta is that it is being related by a master of the subject about the very beginning of his practice where he is, in theory at least, no more knowledgeable about the subject than any beginner then or now.

That this is an instruction for very beginners is the whole point of this sutta. So I think it is not unreasonable to state that the teaching should be taken at face value.

In addition, supporting the idea that this is an instruction that if followed brings the promised result (the getting a grip on the first jhāna) the Buddha's private instruction to Moggallāna is also brought to bear on the subject.

What is needed to be understood about the subject is said, no more, no less.

Because there is doubt surrounding the idea that the jhānas are necessary for full practice of Gotama's system, and where it is also clear that, push come to shove, the first jhāna will do, it is essential that any serious practitioner come to grips with what is required for this attainment.

Here is the rule book. There is the Pāḷi and three translations. Dig in!

Speaking of which, there are those out there that have gone out on a limb and dug themselves into a pit and have jumped from the frying pan into the fire and cut off their noses to spite their faces by stating in no uncertain terms that it is impossible, and ridiculing the idea, that there is thinking in the first jhāna.

Take a look at the Pāḷi.

Just before Moggallāna recalls the formula for the first jhāna,

before he has entered the first jhāna,

in which is found the terms 'sa-vitakka' and 'sa-vicāra'

(my 'with thinking, with pondering',
Woodward's 'accompanied by thought directed and sustained',
Bhk. Bodhi's 'accompanied by thought and examination')

he states that he has been 'pari-vitakka'-ing about the meaning of the term 'The First Knowing'.

Pari-vitakka: 'Thinking about.'

If these terms meant something other than the ordinary understanding of them, to avoid confusion here some distinction would need to be made concerning their use in the one case and their use in the other.

But in stead we have what is actually an emphasis on the idea that these terms are to be understood in the ordinary way by the use of the prefix: 'sa-', 'with.'

The jhānas are a progression of detachments.

"The attaining of one state by the letting go of another."

One begins by letting go of the rough worldly-bound diversions known as the nivaranas.

That does not include all thinking.

We need some stepping stone to the point of even greater detachment wherein there is no thinking (the second knowing): a place where we are able to clearly think and ponder over the Dhamma.

That is the first knowing.

This is something the layman is frequently described as being able to attain without a great deal of labor. You can do it! Do not listen to those who say it cannot be done!




SN 4.40 (the entire Samyutta)

Copyright Statement